Quick Answer
Batt insulation (fibreglass or mineral wool) costs $1.50–$3.00/sq ft installed but provides no air sealing. Closed-cell spray foam is $3.50–$6.00/sq ft and acts as insulation, air barrier, and vapour barrier in one product. Batt for typical OBC R-22 walls; spray foam for retrofits, basements, rim joists, and air-tight assemblies.
Spray foam and batt insulation are the two most common cavity insulation options in GTA residential construction, but they handle different jobs. Batt insulation (fibreglass or mineral wool) is cheap, widely available, and DIY-friendly. Spray foam costs 2-4x as much but works as both insulation and air barrier in one product, which makes it the right choice when air leakage and vapour control matter.
This guide compares both on cost, R-value, installation requirements, and the Ontario assemblies where each performs best in 2026.
Spray Foam vs Batt: Side by Side
Spray foam fills every gap and seals air leaks. Batt fills the cavity but does nothing about gaps or air movement. That difference drives most of the price and performance gap.
The figures below reflect GTA installed pricing for 2026, based on current material costs and installer rates.
| Factor | Batt (Fibreglass/Mineral Wool) | Spray Foam (Closed-Cell) |
|---|---|---|
| R-value per inch | R-3.2 to R-4.0 | R-6.0 to R-6.5 |
| Cost installed (GTA 2026) | $1.60 to $3.25/sq ft | $3.75 to $6.50/sq ft |
| Air barrier? | No | Yes |
| Vapour barrier? | No (separate poly required) | Yes (at 2"+ closed-cell) |
| DIY install? | Yes | No (licensed installer required) |
| Conforms to irregular cavities? | Poor (compression reduces R) | Excellent (expands to fill) |
| Re-entry after install | Immediate | 24 hours typical |
| Removable for renovations? | Easy | Hard (cured foam does not peel out) |
| Soundproofing (mineral wool) | Good | Poor (rigid) |
When Batt Wins
Batt is the right choice when:
- the cavity is regular and accessible, since clean 16" or 24" o.c. stud bays without obstructions take batt in minutes per cavity
- cost is the priority, since batt runs 50-70% less than spray foam at the same R-value
- DIY is on the table, since homeowners can install batt safely with basic PPE and no licensing
- soundproofing matters, since Rockwool ComfortBatt mineral wool is one of the best products for STC-rated party walls and home theatre rooms
- you plan to renovate again, since batt comes out easily during future re-wiring or plumbing changes
- you need to meet the OBC R-22 wall minimum in a 2x6 wall, which batt does with no premium.
For most basement framing and standard wall assemblies, batt is the correct choice.
When Spray Foam Wins
Spray foam is the right choice when:
- air sealing matters, since older Toronto homes can lose 30-40% of their heat through air leaks and see large heating bill reductions after spray foam
- shallow cavities limit batt R-value, since a 2x4 wall cannot reach R-22 with batt in 3.5"
- the assembly is irregular, such as basement walls with stone or rubble foundations, rim joists with offset framing, and cathedral ceilings with intricate roof geometry
- you want insulation and vapour barrier in one pass, since 2" of closed-cell does both and removes the poly sheet labour
- the space is below grade or moisture-prone, since closed-cell rejects water while batt absorbs it
- the project is a high-performance whole-home retrofit where every R-point and air-leakage gain counts toward the maximum Canada Greener Homes Loan and Ontario Home Renovation Savings Program benefits.
Spray foam pays off most in retrofits, where air sealing has the largest dollar impact.
Cost Comparison: Same Wall, Different Insulation
Cost differences widen on whole-home jobs and narrow on small specialty cavities, where batt's labour overhead grows.
Prices below are 2026 GTA installed ranges.
| Application | Batt (R-22) | Closed-cell spray foam |
|---|---|---|
| 1,500 sq ft 2x6 walls (R-22) | $2,400 to $4,900 | $5,600 to $9,750 |
| 1,000 sq ft basement walls (R-20) | $1,600 to $3,250 | $3,750 to $6,500 |
| Rim joist perimeter (200 lin ft) | $425 to $850 (poor seal) | $1,600 to $3,250 (sealed) |
| Cathedral ceiling 800 sq ft (R-31) | $1,700 to $3,450 | $4,300 to $7,350 |
| Single garage 400 sq ft walls + ceiling | $950 to $1,950 | $2,550 to $4,550 |
Hybrid Assemblies: Best of Both
Many Ontario high-performance builds use both products. Installers spray 2-3" of closed-cell foam against the structural element (sheathing, foundation, or roof deck) for air and vapour control, then fill the rest of the cavity with batt or blown-in insulation for bulk R-value. This hybrid approach delivers spray-foam-quality air sealing at 60-70% of pure spray foam cost.
A typical high-performance 2x6 wall in a new build uses 2" of closed-cell foam against the sheathing (R-13, plus air and vapour barrier) and 3.5" of mineral wool batt in the remaining cavity (R-15). The total is R-28, well above the OBC R-22 minimum, at a cost roughly halfway between pure batt and pure foam. We see this assembly more often in custom builds across Toronto and Vaughan.
More Resources
Sources & Methodology
Installed cost ranges from Konstruction Group’s 2024–2026 GTA insulation projects. Air-leakage reduction figures reflect blower-door testing on completed retrofit projects.

Researched & reviewed by
Fadi MamarCo-founder, Konstruction Group Inc
Engineering graduate from Toronto Metropolitan University with 14+ years in Toronto construction. Has overseen 500+ residential and commercial framing, insulation, and drywall projects across the GTA.
LinkedIn ProfileExplore Our Services
Ready to Start Your Project?
Contact Konstruction Group for a free consultation and quote.
Get a Free Quote